Factual Perceptions · Voting
The Secret Ballot Comes to Maine
How Mainers won the right to vote in private, 1891
Before We Begin
Most of us take it for granted that we vote in private. For much of American history, we didn’t.
In many places, voters announced their choice aloud, and in Maine it was often a show of hands. Where paper was used, parties printed their own “tickets,” sometimes in bright colors, so onlookers could tell at a glance how you voted. Employers and anyone offering a bribe could see exactly who you were choosing.
The private ballot is called the “Australian ballot” because it began in Australia in the 1850s. It reached the United States only in the late 1880s. Massachusetts passed the first state law in 1888, and by 1900, 38 states had followed. Maine joined in 1891, about 135 years ago.
The Story in Eight Pictures
Here is how it happened in Maine. The captions are the facts. The characters and their dialogue are illustrative.
A Maine voter's choice was no secret. Elections were run in a way that let others see how you voted, often by a show of hands.
The price of the wrong vote: granite workers in the Rockland area, on Hurricane Island and on Dix Island were reportedly fired, or denied ballots, for supporting a rival party.
The Knights of Labor opened their first Maine local in Portland in 1882. Their argument for a secret ballot: it would stop employers from controlling how their workers vote.
Petitions with about 10,000 signatures backed the cause. On March 7, 1891, Lewiston Rep. T.F. Callahan, a Democrat, urged the Legislature to act.
The new law: ballots printed at state expense, voting shelves screened from view, a guard rail keeping onlookers more than six feet away, and a ten-minute limit in the enclosure.
That Labor Day, marchers in a Portland parade carried a banner reading "The Secret Ballot is the Honest Ballot."
An 1893 amendment grouped candidates in party columns under a "Big Box": one X voted the whole party's ticket. Maine kept the Big Box until a 1972 ballot initiative repealed it.
Maine still has traditional open town meetings. But under state law, a secret-ballot vote on town officials or referendum questions takes precedence over any other voting method at the same meeting.
Sources
- Maine: An Encyclopedia, “Elections”: maineanencyclopedia.com ↗
- Maine State Museum, Labor Mural, “Secret Ballot”: mainestatemuseum.org ↗
- Sun Journal, “A Free Ballot and a Fair Count”: sunjournal.com ↗
- Press Herald, on the Knights of Labor in Maine: pressherald.com ↗
- The Australian or Secret Ballot Law of Maine, as amended (printed 1904): distantreader.org ↗
- Maine Revised Statutes, Title 30-A, section 2528, Secret ballot: legislature.maine.gov ↗
- University of Virginia, First Vote, “Secret Ballot”: firstvote.iath.virginia.edu ↗
- Daily Bulldog, “Early voting and the evolution of Maine’s present voting system”: dailybulldog.com ↗
- Congressional Research Service, “Election Policy Fundamentals: The Secret Ballot”: everycrsreport.com ↗