Westbrook Currents TL;DW! meeting summary · westbrookcurrents.com/tldw/2026-04-07-planning-board
‹ TL;DW! Planning Board

Westbrook Planning Board — April 7, 2026

Westbrook High School (Room 114), 125 Stroudwater St. (Hybrid via Zoom) · 7:00 PM

Attendance: Present: Chair Larry McWilliams, Karen Axelson, Jason Frazier, Kevin Price, Lucas Schrage (alternate). Absent: Vice Chair John Turcotte, Nancy Litrocapes, Robin Tannenbaum, Oriana Farnham (alternate).

Watch the full video on Vimeo ↗ Meeting packet ↗

Each item shows a timestamp like 57:13 (minutes:seconds) or 1:52:13 (hours:minutes:seconds). Tap it to jump to that moment in the video.

Quick read: Planning Board approves 11-unit Pierce Street project, 4–1, over drainage concerns. The board also approved the Redeemer Church relocation and got its first look at Rock Row's Phase 3 master plan.

This was a long meeting (nearly two hours) with an extensive Rock Row Phase 3 presentation; summarization necessarily condenses and selects.

I. Roll Call & Announcements

0:25
Roll Call & Minutes Chair Larry McWilliams called the meeting to order.

Chair Larry McWilliams called the meeting to order. Roll call: five of nine seated members were present (McWilliams, Lucas Schrage, Kevin Price, Jason Frazier, and Karen Axelson). Oriana Farnham, Robin Tannenbaum, Nancy Litrocapes, and Vice Chair John Turcotte were absent.

✓ Minutes of the February 3, 2026 meeting approved unanimously by roll call, 5–0. Moved by Lucas Schrage, seconded by Kevin Price.
2:06
Personnel Announcement — New City Planner Assistant City Administrator Jennie Franceschi announced that Rebecca Spitella has been appointed Director of Planning and Code Enforcement.

Assistant City Administrator Jennie Franceschi announced that Rebecca Spitella has been appointed Director of Planning and Code Enforcement. Spitella will serve as the board's primary presenting city planner going forward, effective after this meeting. Franceschi thanked the board and the development community. She has worked with them over roughly the past decade.

✓ Informational — no vote taken.

New Business

3:08
26-000106 — Conditional Use — 33 Elmwood Ave, Redeemer Church Pastor Joel Miller returned with the Place of Worship conditional use that was workshopped at the March 3 meeting.

Pastor Joel Miller returned with the Place of Worship conditional use that was workshopped at the March 3 meeting. (A conditional use is a use allowed only with board approval and conditions.)

Two site improvements are planned to meet code. One is replacing the front entrance with a double door for better exit capacity. The other is building out an approximately 18.5¢×15¢ room in the rear corner as a childcare/nursery space for Sunday services.

No public comment, no staff concerns, no board discussion.

✓ Approved unanimously by roll call, 5–0 (moved by Kevin Price, seconded by Lucas Schrage).
6:46
25-000758 — Site Plan, Subdivision & Conditional Use — 112 Pierce Street Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers, for applicant Craig Holman/Gopi LLC/Weld LLC) presented a revised site plan.

Dustin Roma (DM Roma Consulting Engineers, for applicant Craig Holman/Gopi LLC/Weld LLC) presented a revised site plan. A site plan is the detailed plan for the project that the Planning Board reviews. It follows an earlier sketch-plan review and board site walk.

The existing two-unit duplex near Pierce Street remains, with minor modifications for a new driveway. A new single-family home is added along the access drive. A 10-unit multifamily building goes at the rear of the site. That makes 11 new units total.

Responding to earlier board feedback, the design now routes all multifamily units through a single front entrance, with interior stairs to basement-level units. This removes the wrap-around exterior entrances shown at the sketch-plan stage.

Several Mayberry Road-area residents spoke about longstanding and worsening drainage problems behind their homes. The homes directly abut the site (see the companion Point/Counterpoint write-up for the full exchange).

Assistant City Administrator Jennie Franceschi explained the board's jurisdiction is limited to making sure the project's post-development runoff rate does not exceed its pre-development rate. The off-site drainage obstructions residents described sit on a neighboring private parcel. They predate the City's current surface-drainage permitting process. So they are a private-property matter outside this project's or the City's authority to compel a fix.

Chair McWilliams pressed the applicant team to reach out to the affected neighboring property owners, even though it falls outside the project's formal responsibility. The applicant's engineer, Dustin Roma, said he hoped the public process would bring the issue to light but did not commit to contacting them.

Member Karen Axelson voted against. She cited ongoing concern about cumulative drainage effects, based on her own prior experience with a large nearby development.

✗ Approved 4–1 by roll call. Moved by Kevin Price, seconded by Lucas Schrage. For: Larry McWilliams, Lucas Schrage, Kevin Price, Jason Frazier. Against: Karen Axelson. Incorporates the findings and conditions in the April 3, 2026 staff memo.

Point/Counterpoint — 112 Pierce St.: New Development vs. Pre-Existing Drainage

The neighbors' case

“That water will stay there for several weeks, if not months... My concern is that [the detention pond] is almost at the level of my backyard... I'm just thinking that my backyard will be saturated.”— Ratanachap Shafro, abutter (public comment, showing a photo of current ponding in his backyard) · 25:57

Shafro, who is on a septic system rather than sewer, raised concern about potential impact to his leach field. Anna Robell 30:16 read a letter into the record citing “engineering flaws or failures of the much smaller development behind their home” as a contributing cause. Robell also urged preserving the hillside's large maple trees as a natural water buffer.

Jim Donnelly, a 25-year resident 32:42, confirmed a “substantial increase in water retention” over time. Donnelly cited a neighbor's sump pump that “basically exploded” during a rain event after being capped off during a remodel.

Elizabeth Bullett 34:36 separately raised concerns about the applicant's financial track record. Bullett cited 77 municipal tax liens recorded against the ownership entities since 1990, since cleared. Bullett also questioned why the project's in-lieu-of-open-space fee was calculated on 11 units rather than the property's eventual 13 total dwelling units.

Staff and applicant's response 22:48 Assistant City Administrator Jennie Franceschi explained the board's jurisdiction is limited to making sure post-development runoff doesn't exceed pre-development rates. The drainage obstructions residents described sit on a neighboring private parcel at 34 Mayberry Road and are a private-property matter between those owners.

Roma explained the engineering team identified two likely causes during their own investigation. One was a narrow, “perched” culvert. The other was retaining-wall fill placed in a drainage ditch on the adjacent parcel, apparently during construction around 2019.

That was before the City's current surface-drainage permitting process existed. So no permit violation exists that staff could enforce retroactively.

On the fee question, Franceschi clarified in-lieu fees apply only to newly created units (11), not units that already existed (the duplex's 2).

“There's enough elevation from one side of that adjacent site to where the water enters that that drainage should be able to be restored in a way that can actually help these folks. Someone just needs to make the effort to do it.”— Dustin Roma, project engineer · 52:59

Chair McWilliams pressed the applicant team to reach out to the two affected neighboring property owners, even though it falls outside this project's formal responsibility. Roma agreed that public review processes like this one are partly why such issues come to light.

Member Lucas Schrage asked whether the new detention system might actually improve on current unmanaged conditions during spring thaw. Roma agreed it likely would, since frozen ground currently prevents infiltration entirely.

Member Jason Frazier reviewed the detention pond's specific elevations. Frazier confirmed with staff that nearby catch basins were cleaned as part of a water-main project the prior summer.

Member Karen Axelson asked whether the ponding area functions as a protected vernal pool (staff: no, it's an altered drainage ditch). She shared that a prior large development changed her own property's water conditions despite similar assurances, and voiced ongoing concern about cumulative effects.

1:11:49
Workshop/Planner's Business — Rock Row Phase 3 Master Plan (No Vote) Josh Levy (Waterstone Properties Group/Dirigo Center Developers, LLC), civil engineer Wayne Morrill (Jones & Beach Engineers), and master planning…

Josh Levy (Waterstone Properties Group/Dirigo Center Developers, LLC), civil engineer Wayne Morrill (Jones & Beach Engineers), and master planning architect David Boyce (Arrow Street, a 1984 Westbrook High School graduate) presented a conceptual master plan for Rock Row's next phase.

They sought board feedback ahead of individual site plan submissions for each building. No vote was requested; this was informational only.

Background & Phase 3 scope 1:13:08 The developer purchased the roughly 100-acre former Blue Rock Quarry site from Pike Industries about eight and a half years ago. The site was already permitted for a 550,000-square-foot single-story shopping center. That plan was abandoned in favor of the mixed-use development seen today.

Phase One (Market Basket, REI, Chick-fil-A, Starbucks, opened 2020) has drawn 19 million total visits. That includes 4.4 million last year and 960,000 unique customers. The healthcare campus has served roughly 150,000 patients since opening in 2025.

Phase 3 sits between the restored Nason's Brook and the rail line, bordered by Larrabee Road and the turnpike. The plan includes a 267-unit apartment building with an adjoining 7-story, 700-space parking garage topped with retail. That is the first component to be formally filed this week.

The plan also includes 12 condo townhomes along the brook, loft office space over ground-floor retail, a small-footprint hotel, and an entertainment/recreation building. Zoning allows up to 85% building coverage. This plan approaches but doesn't reach that maximum.

The applicant's goal is to begin vertical construction roughly a year from now. Retail would open by the end of 2027, and residential, hotel and office openings would roll into 2028. Each building component will return to the board individually for formal site plan review.

Point/Counterpoint — design philosophy

“This is an asset limited, income constrained community. This is a river city, it is a mill town... I would love to see the people that already live in this community be able to use Phase three... not pulling in people from other communities.”— Member Lucas Schrage · 1:33:53

Schrage encouraged the developer to consider affordable or mixed-income housing, given the project's scale. The project was cited at roughly $600 million.

“I kind of counter that. I say go luxury. Go big or go home... Westbrook needs that... some luxury high-end.”— Member Jason Frazier · 1:37:11

Frazier praised the development's coordination with Metro on bus access and encouraged further bike-lane connectivity to Portland.

Member Kevin Price suggested the retail mix include more informal "third place" gathering spaces that don't require a purchase to use 1:46:11. Price also encouraged recruiting established local and regional businesses rather than relying solely on national chains.

Member Karen Axelson recalled attending early community meetings about the project back in 2019. Axelson asked about plans for the flooded quarry pit.

Josh Levy described an unresolved, still-evolving concept. It would stop the rising water level before it reaches the surface, to preserve a rock outcropping for potential outdoor movie nights or projected light shows. This depends on resolving wall-stability and safe public-access questions that remain unstudied in detail.

Levy clarified that a proposed enclosed entertainment/conference venue and a long-discussed movie theater are both being considered for a later phase, not Phase 3.

Chair McWilliams recalled being on the City Council when Rock Row was first proposed. McWilliams praised the project's walkability and tree-planting plans.

Not a replacement for watching — and not an official record. This summary highlights the meeting's key discussions and decisions; it's not a substitute for watching the full meeting, and summarization necessarily condenses and selects. It's also an unofficial product of Westbrook Currents, an independent site — not the City of Westbrook — and may contain mistakes. For complete context or the official record, watch the full video or see the City's approved minutes.

How this was made: Produced from the meeting video (linked above, hosted on the City's Vimeo showcase). The audio was transcribed with AI-assisted speech-to-text and speaker identification. This process cross-checked names against the official Planning Board roster, attributed speakers from context (introductions, roll-call order, direct address by the Chair) rather than the raw diarization labels alone, and drafted this summary and the quoted excerpts. Quotes are lightly cleaned of filler words/false starts but not reworded. Reviewed by Gerald Doyon. A separate AI accuracy check then compared this summary against the transcript and agenda packet. Errors it found were corrected, and Gerald Doyon verified against the meeting video the points only the video could settle.