TL;DW! meeting summary · westbrookcurrents.com/tldw/2026-05-12-zoning-board-of-appeals Westbrook Zoning Board of Appeals — May 12, 2026
Attendance: Present: Interim Vice Chair Cliff McCarthy (alternate), Nancy Heath, Sherri Quint, Kevin Moss (alternate). Absent: Chair Aaron Burns, Vice Chair Keith Richard, Peter Mancuso.
Each item shows a timestamp like 57:13 (minutes:seconds) or 1:52:13 (hours:minutes:seconds). Tap it to jump to that moment in the video.
Quick read: Hammond Road garage variance approved; no one spoke against it. The Chair and Vice Chair were both absent, so the board chose an interim Vice Chair. It then approved a rear-setback variance for an attached garage by a show of hands, after going through the seven required criteria.
I. Interim Vice Chair & Roll Call
Interim Vice Chair Election & Roll Call With Chair Aaron Burns and Vice Chair Keith Richard both absent, City Attorney Gray Lewis opened the meeting and oversaw election of an interim Vic…
With Chair Aaron Burns and Vice Chair Keith Richard both absent, City Attorney Gray Lewis opened the meeting and oversaw election of an interim Vice Chair for the night. Cliff McCarthy was nominated and elected, 3 in favor and 1 abstaining.
Roll call: Nancy Heath, Sherri Quint, Kevin Moss, and Cliff McCarthy present; Burns, Richard, and Peter Mancuso absent. The Feb. 10, 2026 minutes were then approved, 4–0.
✓ Cliff McCarthy elected interim Vice Chair, 3–0 with one abstention. The motion to elect an interim Vice Chair was moved by Sherri Quint and seconded by Nancy Heath; Heath then nominated McCarthy. For: Nancy Heath, Sherri Quint, and one of Kevin Moss and Cliff McCarthy; which of those two abstained is not clear on the recording. Feb. 10, 2026 minutes approved 4–0 by show of hands. Moved by Kevin Moss, seconded by Cliff McCarthy.Variance Request
96 Hammond Road — Practical Difficulty Variance Tax Map 44, Lot 87, Residential Growth Area 2.
Tax Map 44, Lot 87, Residential Growth Area 2. The request is for a 4.99-foot rear setback variance. A setback is the required distance from a property line, and a variance is permission to break a zoning rule because of a hardship. It would allow construction of a 26-by-26-foot attached garage with living space above.
The applicant's name is rendered inconsistently in the recording as “Erica/Daniel Higginbottom” (as the item was introduced) and “Danielle Hagenbotham” (self-introduction). The correct spelling could not be confirmed because no agenda was published.
Background
The house was built in 1939. It was relocated to its current foundation in October 2005, per a building permit referenced during the hearing. At that time the original larger parcel was subdivided so a new house could be built on the adjoining lot.
Code Enforcement Officer (CEO) Brian Stetson testified that the house appears to have been sited to align with the curve of the street. It was not placed squarely within the new, smaller lot's boundaries. That left it angled in a way that now makes a conventional rear addition impossible without a setback variance.
The current owners, who bought the property in 2018, are requesting the variance to accommodate their growing family.
The applicant's case
The applicant testified the addition would let the family stay in a house and neighborhood they love rather than move. She had discussed the project informally with both abutting neighbors by text message (not formal letters). Both indicated support. One noted the addition would actually increase their own backyard privacy.
The applicant described considering alternatives (a smaller footprint, an angled addition, converting the existing deck). She concluded the lot's shape and the house's angled placement meant some setback intrusion was unavoidable. She cited a comparable, previously approved variance nearby and noted most neighborhood homes already have garages.
Board discussion and the seven-part standard
City Attorney Lewis walked the board through Westbrook's “practical difficulty” variance standard. First, strict enforcement must cause a practical difficulty (precluding a permitted use and significant economic injury). There are also six further criteria:
- Unique property circumstances (not general neighborhood conditions).
- No undesirable change to neighborhood character or harm to abutting property values.
- The difficulty isn't the result of the applicant's or a prior owner's own actions.
- No feasible alternative exists.
- No adverse effect on the natural environment.
- The property isn't within a shoreland area.
Partway through, the board briefly realized it had skipped the “prior owner's actions” criterion, and circled back to it. It debated whether the 2005 relocation (apparently aligned to the street rather than the new lot lines) counted as a disqualifying prior action.
City Attorney Lewis advised that “prior owner” is generally read to mean any prior owner. Lewis also advised that siting the house to suit the slope could still count as an action taken. Lewis said the board could interpret the criterion itself.
The board concluded the placement read as an oversight rather than an intentional choice, and that the criterion should be read to mean an intentional act.
CEO Stetson confirmed no neighbor complaints had been received and the property isn't in a resource-protection or shoreland zone.
Six criteria were found met, each by a 4–0 show of hands. The seventh, on shoreland location, was confirmed by informal agreement without a separate vote. The board then approved the variance by a show of hands, 4–0, on a second by Nancy Heath.
✓ Six variance criteria found met, 4–0 each; the seventh (property not in a shoreland area) confirmed by informal agreement without a separate vote. No motions; each criterion voted by show of hands.✓ Variance approved by a show of hands, 4–0. Moved by Kevin Moss, seconded by Nancy Heath.Action items
- The board authorized interim Vice Chair Cliff McCarthy to review and sign off on the written Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, once City Attorney Lewis drafts them. The board does not have to reconvene for this. The appeal window begins once the signed decision is issued.
- City Attorney Lewis to follow up on whether the applicant must register the variance with the Cumberland County Registry of Deeds within a set window. He did not have a definitive answer on the record.
How this was made: Produced from the meeting video (linked above). The audio was transcribed with AI-assisted speech-to-text and speaker identification. This process cross-checked names against the official Zoning Board of Appeals roster, attributed speakers from context (self-identification, direct address, roll-call order, and consistency with this pipeline's established recurring staff roles) rather than the raw diarization labels alone, and drafted this summary and the quoted excerpts. No agenda was published for this meeting; it was processed from the video/transcript alone per this pipeline's standing practice for meetings with no published agenda. This meeting is unrelated to the Feb. 10, 2026 Zoning Board of Appeals meeting's 640 Saco Street appeal. Reviewed by Gerald Doyon. A separate AI accuracy check then compared this summary against the transcript and agenda packet. Errors it found were corrected, and Gerald Doyon verified against the meeting video the points only the video could settle.